Design Evaluation
SeanJ1ang/design-judge-skillsEvaluate one design or a user-approved maturity-mapped batch through a transparent evidence-based rubric. Classify each work, score design quality and presentation, identify Critical risks, report evidence confidence, and optionally shortlist works within separate maturity tracks. Use when a user asks to judge, score, critique, review, diagnose, batch-evaluate, or rank designs by evidence-aligned evaluation score. Do not use this skill to retrieve winners, choose an award, produce a redesign, audit submission-file compliance, simulate an official jury, or predict winning probability.
At a glance
This skill is for Presentations and helps you evaluate design quality against a rubric, score and critique a design presentation, and batch-review multiple designs with maturity mapping.
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/SeanJ1ang/design-judge-skills
cp -r design-judge-skills/skills/design-evaluation ~/.claude/skills/design-evaluation
Setup, runtime and requirements describe SeanJ1ang/design-judge-skills, the repo this skill ships in.
RubricCritiqueScoringDesign AssessmentEvidence Based EvaluationQuality Assurance
Also in SeanJ1ang/design-judge-skills
View the repoMatch a design project to supported design-award programs, tracks, and entry categories; apply structural eligibility gates; verify current...
Route and coordinate an end-to-end design-award workflow across winner research, evidence-based evaluation, award matching, entry-text prepa...
Find and verify award-winning designs in the same or adjacent functional category through eight explicit relevance dimensions: problem and u...
Extract evidence-grounded project facts from user-provided design attachments, identify missing information, and prepare the exact written f...
Shared support package for the Design Judge skill collection. Install it with design-award-search and design-award-match so those skills can...
Audit a design-award submission package against the current official rules for a specific award cycle. Check required materials and technica...
Other Presentations skills
Toolkit for styling artifacts with a theme. These artifacts can be slides, docs, reportings, HTML landing pages, etc. There are 10 pre-set t...
Use this skill any time a .pptx or .potx file is involved in any way — as input, output, or both. This includes: creating slide decks, pitch...
Open Design's Series A growth story: the traction curve, the expansion motion, and why it's venture-scale. Built as a decision-grade fundrai...
Hyperframes-based video template for retro pixel deck motion design. Use when users want a high-fidelity, multi-scene HTML-to-video composit...
Open Design's community-growth campaign across GitHub, Discord, and X: the loops, the content calendar, and the pipeline math. Built as a de...
Open Design's QBR for the executive committee: what moved, what stalled, and the resource reallocation ask. Built as a decision-grade corpor...